Matt Deegan
A Factual Funding Crisis & Joe Lycett's Churnalism

The Media Club · 19 April 2024 · 41 min

A Factual Funding Crisis & Joe Lycett's Churnalism

With Faraz Osman, Kimberly Godbolt

Listen and watch at themediaclub.com →AppleSpotifyYouTube

In this episode of The Media Club, host Matt Deegan is joined by Faraz Osman, MD of Gold Wala, and Kimberly Godbolt, co-founder of Talented People, to discuss the week's media news. The panel examines the threat to documentary features due to the ad recession, the BBC's 'Across the UK' regional production plans and criticism from MPs, and the BBC's consideration of performance-related pay for top earners. They also analyse Joe Lycett's publicity stunt involving fake news stories, the implications for journalism and trust, and the controversy at NPR over a senior editor's resignation. The episode includes a media quiz segment and listener survey promotion.

Key takeaways

  • The panel discussed the threat to documentary features due to the ad recession and the need for multiple funding partners.
  • MPs criticised the BBC's 'Across the UK' plan for moving production, questioning the purpose of allocated funds.
  • The BBC is considering performance-related pay for top earners, sparking debate on what 'performance' means in a public service context.
  • Joe Lycett launched his new Channel 4 series with a stunt involving fake news stories, raising concerns about media trust.
  • NPR faced controversy after senior editor Yuri Berliner resigned over perceived progressive bias.

In this episode

  • Intro and News in Brief0:00 · Matt introduces the show and covers news about Hugh Grant, Henry Winter, and Olivia Williams.
  • Documentary Funding Crisis0:00 · Panel discusses the threat to documentary features and the need for multiple funding partners.
  • BBC Across the UK and Performance Pay0:00 · Discussion on MPs' criticism of BBC's regional plans and performance-related pay.
  • Joe Lycett's Churnalism Stunt0:00 · Analysis of Joe Lycett's fake news stories and implications for journalism.
  • NPR Controversy0:00 · Discussion on Yuri Berliner's resignation and NPR's trust issues.
  • Media Quiz0:00 · Stat Attack quiz with stats on gender pay gap, The 1% Club, and Pick of the Pops.

Notable quotes

I would love to see all the allegations that they deny tested in court, but the rules around civil litigation mean that if I proceed to trial and the court awards me damages that are even a penny less than the settlement offer, I would have to pay the legal costs of both sides.
Hugh Grant1:01
Friends was a brand and you had to fit the brand and that involved essentially plucking off your eyebrows. I said, please don't take my eyebrows off. I might need them another job.
Olivia Williams1:39
I think that the point that Joe was trying to make is that it is really easy to get these stories out there. Therefore, the problem with it is that it ends up going, well, you shouldn't trust the news network and you shouldn't trust any news. Everything's fake news.
Faraz Osman23:35
I think that this is, you know, in balance, this is a good thing. If he was a bit like, look, we put out this press release, if anybody called the number at the bottom of the press release to check the story, we would have told them it was fake.
Faraz Osman27:55

Discussed

Joe Lycett · BBC · Channel 4 · NPR

Also mentioned: Hugh Grant · Henry Winter · Olivia Williams · Yuri Berliner · Nick Davies · Chris Sawyer · Mark Goodyear · Alex Zane · Gold Wala · Talented People · ITV · GB News · The Sun · The Times · The Independent · BAFTA · Motion Content Group · Rogan Productions · Left Handed · Bournemouth University · PBS · Radio 2 · Radio 1 · Acast

Mentioned or recommended

  • Defiance · tv show · Rogan Productions and Left Handed
  • Three Identical Strangers · film · Tim Wardle
  • Superman · film
  • Flat Earth News · book · Nick Davies
  • The 1% Club · tv show · ITV
  • Gladiators · tv show · ITV
  • Pick of the Pops · tv show · BBC
  • This American Life · other · Chicago Public Media
  • Sesame Street · tv show · Sesame Workshop
  • The Imposter Club · other · Talented People
  • Countdown to the BAFTAs · tv show · BAFTA