Matt Deegan

The Media Club · 30 September 2022 · 40 min

BBC World Service cutbacks, the new Times boss & a royal censorship controversy. Plus Ian Rumsey on true crime

With Janine Gibson, Jim Waterson, Steven D Wright, Ian Rumsey

Listen at themediaclub.com →AppleSpotify

In this episode of The Media Club, host Jake Kanter is joined by Janine Gibson (FT), Jim Waterson (The Guardian), and Steven D Wright (TV producer) to discuss the BBC World Service's job cuts, Tony Gallagher's appointment as editor of The Times, and the royal family's censorship of Queen Elizabeth II's funeral footage. The panel also features a deep dive into true crime television with ITN's Ian Rumsey, and a media quiz celebrating International Podcast Day.

Key takeaways

  • The BBC World Service announced 328 job cuts, attributed to the licence fee freeze and a digital-first strategy.
  • Tony Gallagher was confirmed as the new editor of The Times, replacing John Witherow.
  • The royal family had a veto over footage from the Queen's funeral, leading to censorship concerns.
  • ITN's Ian Rumsey discussed the duty of care in true crime production, highlighting the importance of not sensationalising victims.
  • The media quiz celebrated International Podcast Day with questions about new podcast announcements.

In this episode

  • Introduction and News Roundup0:00 · Host Jake Kanter introduces the show and gives a quick news roundup including Khashoggi anniversary, Trevor Noah leaving The Daily Show, Sky Stream launch, and Daily Mail/Mail Online collaboration.
  • BBC World Service Cutbacks Discussion2:00 · Panel discusses the BBC World Service job cuts and their implications for soft power and digital transition.
  • Times Editorial Change Discussion12:00 · Panel discusses Tony Gallagher's appointment as editor of The Times and the paper's political direction.
  • Deep Dive: True Crime with Ian Rumsey20:00 · Matt Deegan interviews ITN's Ian Rumsey about true crime production and duty of care.
  • Royal Censorship Discussion30:00 · Jim Waterson discusses his investigation into royal censorship of Queen's funeral footage.
  • Media Quiz: International Podcast Day Special40:00 · Quiz about new podcast announcements, with questions about Beebwatch, Fortunately, and Martin Lewis's podcast.
  • Outro and Listener Survey50:00 · Wrap-up, thanks to guests, and promotion of Patreon and listener survey.

Notable quotes

“It's the beginning of the end for the World Service as we know it with the sort of idea of people tuning in on shortwave radios all over the world listening to the news from London.”

Jim Waterson · 0:00

“It is censorship. There's no way you're addressing this up. It's nothing to do with the royal family being concerned about grief or anything else. This is power.”

Steven D Wright · 0:00

“The original sin is the George Osborne funding change.”

Janine Gibson · 0:00

“You can have all the psych tests in the world and you can have great duty of care. And I know that you have that and that's all good. But he said, sometimes it's about the producer phoning you up a week later, a month later, and just saying, you're okay.”

Ian Rumsey · 0:00

“It's brinkmanship, though, isn't it? That they shouldn't pay for it from the licence fee. The government wants these services to exist and they should be funding them.”

Janine Gibson · 0:00

Discussed

Tony Gallagher · BBC · The Times · The Guardian · ITN

Also mentioned: John Witherow · Deborah Turness · George Osborne · Sarah Payne · Martin Lewis · Roger Bolton · Nicola Gill · Michael Gove · Emma Tucker · Rebecca Brooks · Trevor Noah · Jamal Khashoggi · David Ignatius · Mike Tindall · Charles III · Queen Elizabeth II · Phoebe Adler-Ryan · Matt Hill · Financial Times · Netflix · Amazon · Sky · ITV · Channel 4

Mentioned or recommended

  • The Crown · tv show · Peter Morgan
  • The Confession · tv show · ITN Productions
  • History 101 · tv show · ITN Productions
  • Beebwatch · podcast · Roger Bolton
  • Fortunately · podcast · Jane Garvey and Fi Glover
  • The Edit · product · Financial Times
  • Sky Stream · product · Sky
  • The Daily Show · tv show · Comedy Central
  • Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power · tv show · Amazon Studios
  • House of the Dragon · tv show · HBO
  • This England · tv show · Michael Winterbottom