Matt Deegan

The Media Club · 24 February 2023 · 41 min

‘Death knocks’ in 2023, Bob ‘Icebreaker’ Iger & newsrooms get scruffier

With Jamie East, Paul Robinson

Listen at themediaclub.com →AppleSpotify

In this episode of The Media Club, hosts Matt Deegan and Jamie East, along with TV and radio consultant Paul Robinson, discuss the media coverage of Nicola Bulley's disappearance and the subsequent Ofcom complaints against ITV and Sky News. They also debate the value of paid verification on social media platforms following Meta's announcement, and explore the warming relations between Disney and China, with insights from Paul Robinson on Bob Iger's strategy. The episode includes a media quiz on recent TV deals and a discussion on the BBC's relaxed dress code for news presenters.

Key takeaways

  • Ofcom issued a formal statement in response to complaints about ITV and Sky News contacting Nicola Bulley's family despite privacy appeals.
  • Meta announced paid verification for Instagram and Facebook at $12 a month, testing in Australia and New Zealand.
  • Disney's relationship with China appears to be warming, with Avatar: The Way of Water performing well and Bob Iger leading the charge.
  • BBC News presenters have been told to relax their dress code as part of a channel relaunch, sparking debate.
  • BBC Studios' branded content for Huawei achieved a 61% uplift, raising concerns about labelling and editorial integrity.

In this episode

  • Intro and news round-up0:00 · Matt introduces the show and covers top media news stories.
  • Nicola Bulley coverage discussion0:00 · Panel discusses Ofcom complaints and media ethics in the Nicola Bulley case.
  • Paid verification debate0:00 · Discussion on Meta's paid verification and its implications.
  • Disney-China relations0:00 · Paul Robinson and Jamie East discuss Disney's warming ties with China.
  • BBC dress code and Huawei content0:00 · Panel debates BBC's relaxed dress code and branded content for Huawei.
  • Media quiz0:00 · Quiz on recent TV deals, including Boris series and Eurovision postcards.
  • Outro and plugs0:00 · Wrap-up, Patreon plug, and social media requests.

Notable quotes

“It's created this weird fever dream that the whole country seems to have been in over it.”

Jamie East · 0:00

“If you're piloting something 29 times, there is something intrinsically wrong with the original idea.”

Jamie East · 0:00

“I think paying for a blue tick is very, very dangerous and in fact encourages more impersonation and risks those who are the genuine article if they choose not to blue tick.”

Paul Robinson · 0:00

“Within 24 hours, having a blue tick became an embarrassment, rather than an aspiration.”

Jamie East · 0:00

“The risk is that if you compromise, you end up with a camel, not a racehorse, which satisfies nobody.”

Paul Robinson · 0:00

“It's the Zelensky effect for me, is what it is.”

Jamie East · 0:00

Discussed

BBC · Disney · Meta

Also mentioned: Nicola Bulley · Bob Iger · Mark Zuckerberg · Elon Musk · Will Ferrell · Michael Sheen · James Graham · Adam Curtis · Naja Nielsen · Evan Harris · Stuart Purvis · Christopher Hope · Max Cutler · Michael Booker · Jacob Rees-Mogg · Ken Bruce · Angela Rippon · John Simpson · Kirsty Wark · James Cridland · Duncan Jones · Matt Damon · Tom Holland · Tatiana Siegel

Mentioned or recommended

  • Avatar: The Way of Water · film · James Cameron
  • Black Panther: Wakanda Forever · film · Ryan Coogler
  • Toy Story · film · Pixar
  • Buzz Lightyear of Star Command · tv show · Disney
  • Toy Story 5 · film · Pixar
  • Frozen 3 · film · Disney
  • Warcraft · film · Duncan Jones
  • The Great Wall · film · Zhang Yimou
  • Uncharted · film · Ruben Fleischer
  • Eternals · film · Chloé Zhao
  • Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings · film · Destin Daniel Cretton
  • Mulan · film · Disney
  • Kung Fu Panda · film · DreamWorks Animation
  • Avengers: Endgame · film · Marvel Studios
  • The Fate of the Furious · film · F. Gary Gray
  • Boris · tv show · 72 Films
  • Eurovision Song Contest 2023 · event · European Broadcasting Union
  • Doctor Who · tv show · BBC
  • The Smart 7 · podcast · Jamie East