Matt Deegan

The Media Club · 9 December 2022 · 51 min

The BBC's Digital Future, A Media Policy Stocktake, & Scott Bryan's Xmas TV RoundUp!

With Ed Vaizey, Maggie Brown, Jim Waterson, Scott Bryan

Listen at themediaclub.com →AppleSpotify

In this episode of The Media Club, host Faraz Osman is joined by former Culture Minister Lord Ed Vaizey, media commentator and Channel 4 historian Maggie Brown, and The Guardian's media editor Jim Waterson. The panel discusses Tim Davie's vision for an online-only future for the BBC, the state of the Media Bill, the potential hybrid funding model for Channel 4, and the legacy of outgoing Sky News chief John Ryley. TV critic Scott Bryan joins for a deep dive into Christmas TV recommendations, and the show concludes with a media quiz and reflections on the year's media policy debates.

Key takeaways

  • Tim Davie outlined a vision for an online-only future for the BBC, with a focus on digital adaptation.
  • The panel discussed the status of the Media Bill, with ITV threatening to abandon PSB status if it is not passed.
  • Channel 4 privatisation appears to have been shelved, but a hybrid funding model with a commercial partner is possible.
  • John Ryley is stepping down as head of Sky News after 16 years, with his legacy praised by the panel.
  • Scott Bryan recommended Christmas TV including ITVX's Litvinenko and A Spy Among Friends, and the return of Happy Valley.

In this episode

  • Intro and News Roundup0:00 · Host Faraz Osman introduces the episode and reads the week's media news.
  • Interview with Lord Ed Vaizey5:00 · Discussion on Tim Davie's BBC vision, the Media Bill, and politicians in media.
  • Deep Dive: Scott Bryan's Christmas TV Recommendations25:00 · Scott Bryan shares his picks for holiday viewing.
  • Sky News Discussion40:00 · Maggie Brown and Jim Waterson reflect on John Ryley's legacy and Sky's future.
  • Media Quiz50:00 · The panel plays the media quiz, with Jim Waterson winning.
  • Outro55:00 · Wrap-up and thanks to guests.

Notable quotes

“I thought it was a pretty good speech.”

Ed Vaizey · 0:00

“I thought that what he said this week made a lot of sense.”

Jim Waterson · 0:00

“I think Tim is right. It's more than just blue sky thinking this.”

Maggie Brown · 0:00

“It's not got much intellectual coherence. It's based on slightly sort of knee-jerk tribal instincts.”

Ed Vaizey · 0:00

“I would kill to go on I'm a Celebrity and I think that you will see Matt Hancock becoming a major Media star, which fills me with absolute horror and bitterness and chippiness because he's a nightmare to work with as a minister.”

Ed Vaizey · 0:00

“I think that the privatisation, pure and simple, is something that is so difficult to get through.”

Maggie Brown · 0:00

Discussed

BBC · Channel 4 · Sky News

Also mentioned: Tim Davie · John Ryley · Michael Gove · Nadine Dorries · Matt Hancock · Rupert Murdoch · Michelle Donelan · Peter Fincham · Kay Burley · Beth Rigby · Piers Morgan · Alan Davey · Claudia Winkleman · David Tennant · Sarah Lancashire · James Norton · Sally Wainwright · Martin Compston · ITV · Netflix · Amazon Prime Video · Disney+ · GB News · LBC

Mentioned or recommended

  • The Crown · tv show · Peter Morgan
  • Happy Valley · tv show · Sally Wainwright
  • The Rig · tv show · David Macpherson
  • Litvinenko · tv show · George Kay
  • A Spy Among Friends · tv show · Alexander Cary
  • The Traitors · tv show · Studio Lambert
  • Big Brother · tv show · Endemol
  • Gladiators · tv show
  • Survivor · tv show · Charlie Parsons
  • No Time to Die · film · Cary Joji Fukunaga
  • Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special · tv show · James Gunn
  • Strictly Come Dancing · tv show · BBC
  • Call the Midwife · tv show · Heidi Thomas
  • All Creatures Great and Small · tv show · Ben Vanstone
  • Gone Fishing · tv show
  • The Greatest Snowman · tv show
  • Harry & Meghan · tv show · Liz Garbus
  • License to Be Different · book · Maggie Brown
  • Channel 4: From Big Brother to the Great British Bake Off · book · Maggie Brown
  • Ringside Seat · book · Maggie Brown
  • I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here! · tv show · ITV Studios