Matt Deegan

The Media Club · 22 August 2025 · 50 min

Was This The Bitchiest TV Festival Ever?

With Rebecca Cooney, Boyd Hilton, Jake Kanter, Faraz Osman, Heather Fallon, Jordan Laird, Leon Wilson

Listen at themediaclub.com →AppleSpotify

This special episode of The Media Club, recorded live at the Edinburgh International TV Festival, covers the festival's key themes: the perceived 'bitchiness' and sniping between broadcasters and streamers, the debate over Netflix's 'TV tourism' (coined by Louisa Compton), and the decision to have newspaper editor James Harding deliver the McTaggart lecture. Guests including Boyd Hilton, Rebecca Cooney, Jake Kanter, Faraz Osman, Heather Fallon, and Jordan Laird discuss sessions on Channel 4, Channel 5, and the streamers' reduced presence. Leon Wilson from Banijay UK reveals the new Last One Laughing line-up and discusses MasterChef's move to Birmingham. The episode also includes a media quiz and news round-up.

Key takeaways

  • The Edinburgh TV Festival was marked by public sniping between broadcasters and streamers, with Louisa Compton coining 'TV tourists' for Netflix.
  • James Harding's McTaggart lecture warned that the BBC could cease to exist if its Royal Charter is not renewed in 2027, and called for safeguards against political interference.
  • Leon Wilson revealed the new Last One Laughing line-up and discussed MasterChef's move to Birmingham, with two series already filmed there.
  • Channel 4 announced it is doubling its drama spend, while Channel 5's Ben Frow confirmed the channel will not be sold as part of the Skydance merger.
  • Wondery cut nearly its entire workforce (110 layoffs), and Reach is moving its overnight team to Australia.

In this episode

  • Intro and Festival Gossip0:00 · Matt Deegan introduces the Edinburgh special and discusses the 'bitchy' atmosphere with Rebecca Cooney and Boyd Hilton.
  • Last One Laughing and MasterChef0:00 · Leon Wilson discusses the success of Last One Laughing and MasterChef's move to Birmingham.
  • Channel 4 and Channel 5 Sessions0:00 · Heather Fallon and Faraz Osman recap the Channel 4 and Channel 5 sessions, including Ben Frow's comments.
  • Small Indy Fund and Studio Something0:00 · Jordan Laird talks about Studio Something and the Small Indy Fund.
  • News Round-up0:00 · Matt Deegan covers Wondery layoffs, Wired AI article, and Reach's Australia move.
  • McTaggart Lecture Discussion0:00 · Jake Kanter discusses James Harding's McTaggart lecture on BBC independence.
  • Media Quiz: The Weakest Format0:00 · Rebecca and Boyd play a true/false quiz on commissioning announcements.

Notable quotes

“the bitches, the bitches of the local festival.”

Rebecca Cooney · 0:00

“He's a genius. I think he's completely reinvented television. And I take my hat off to his originality and creativity.”

Ben Frow · 0:00

“If Parliament chooses not to renew the Royal Charter in 2027, the BBC will just cease to exist.”

James Harding · 0:00

“I consider it to be Stephen Moffat's West Wing.”

Boyd Hilton · 0:00

Discussed

James Harding · BBC · Channel 4 · Channel 5 · Netflix · Amazon Prime Video

Also mentioned: Louisa Compton · Ben Frow · Ian Katz · Kate Phillips · Stephen Moffat · Greg Wallace · Lisa Nandy · Donald Trump · Danny Dyer · Richard Gadd · Francis Bourgeois · Craig Morris · Alice Redmond · Richard Bacon · Jack Thorne · Stephen Graham · Russell T. Davies · Charlotte Moore · Vanessa Phelps · Jimmy Carr · Romesh Ranganathan · David Mitchell · Diane Morgan · Alan Carr

Mentioned or recommended

  • Edinburgh International TV Festival · event
  • Last One Laughing · tv show · Amazon Prime Video
  • MasterChef · tv show · BBC
  • The Traitors · tv show · BBC
  • Celebrity Traitors · tv show · BBC
  • Adolescence · tv show · Netflix
  • Toxic Town · tv show · Netflix
  • The Night Manager · tv show · BBC
  • Big Brother · tv show · Endemol
  • A View from the Terrace · tv show · Studio Something
  • Hunted · tv show · Shine
  • The Summit · tv show · Shine
  • Francis Bourgeois astronaut show · tv show · Shine
  • Number 10 · tv show · Stephen Moffat
  • Danny Dyer saves a caravan park · tv show · Sky
  • The Weakest Format · other · The Media Club
  • British Scandal · podcast · Wondery